Prescriptivism and Descriptivism:
Prescriptivism
– The attitude or belief that one variety of a language is superior to others and should be
promoted as such. A key aspect of traditional
grammar, prescriptivism is characterized by a concern for
"good," "proper," or "correct" usage. It contrasts with descriptivism.
Descriptivism
– A non-judgemental approach to language that
focuses on how it is actually spoken and written. Contrast with prescriptivism.
Well known prescriptivists include:
Skinner
Pullum
Dryden
Bernstein
Crystal
Well known descriptivists include:
Chomsky
Wrenn
Williams
Webster
Noam
Chomsky, a famous linguist, has a descriptivist point of view. He believes that
language is innate which fits in to the view that prescriptivism in language is
artificial language and descriptivism is natural. However he also sees the
other side to the argument that the specifics of standard grammar in Standard
English should be learnt as part of an education – “I think sensible
prescriptivism ought to be part of an education”. – Noam Chomsky 1991. This
view shows a non negative attitude to variations in accent in dialect unlike
prescriptivism which is arguably the source of negative attitudes towards
accents like that of the ‘stealing’ Scouse or the ‘unintelligible’ Brummy.
Some good work but Crystal is decidedly descriptivist!
ReplyDelete